Silliness With Numbers
September 29th, 2015Joe tries to keep an open mind about the stat geeks. Really.
Some stats are useful. Hey, Joe uses them every day and so do just about all fans of sports, even if it is just yards-per-carry or completion percentage or, for example in baseball, batting average and ERA.
But this myriad of statistical graffiti and half-baked acronyms is over the top and someone needs to put a stop to it.
This brings Joe to the con artists over at Pro Football Focus.
Joe share some of their stuff (again, Joe tries to keep an open mind), it is occasionally insightful. But if you are paying good money for folks with little or no football background to try to convince you Nick Foles is a better quarterback than Aaron Rodgers or Andrew Luck, you need to contact your local office of the Better Business Bureau.
Will Brinson of CBS Sports pointed out an outrageous grading by the spreadsheeters, where they contend America’s Quarterback, Bucs signal-caller Jameis Winston, among others, had a better game this week than Rodgers.
Love me some @PFF but Aaron Rodgers was not worse than Nick Foles, Jameis Winston or Blake Bortles this week. pic.twitter.com/F4BYr7PR17
— Will Brinson (@WillBrinson) September 29, 2015
Regular readers of Joe know and should fully understand that Joe is in the tank for Jameis. But only perhaps Jameis’ parents, girlfriend and a raging blind drunk would suggest Jameis had better game than Rodgers this week. To suggest otherwise is just asinine. To front numbers that claim Jameis outplayed Rodgers, well, someone needs to tinker with their software.
This is just like this offseason, when the Pro Football Focus crowd claimed Luck, was not a top-10 quarterback. If that wasn’t bad enough, they doubled-down with a column backing up their stats. In fact, the same crowd claimed Luck was the worst quarterback in the NFL, worse than Josh McClown, even!
Joe is sure just about every NFL general manager reading was rolling on the ground in pain, crippled with laughter.
As always, common sense must applied and critical thinking should be used with stats. Anyone, and Joe means anyone, who watched Jameis play Sunday, and then watched Rodgers masterfully dissect the Chiefs last night, would tell you who the better quarterback of the week was.
Sometimes, people have to get their heads out of the spreadsheets and actually watch a game.
And people actually pay good money for this nonsense?
September 29th, 2015 at 12:10 pm
I was more or less still laughing at the YUCS defense on Sunday and how Alfred MUTHAFUKIN Blue became an All Pro that day.
September 29th, 2015 at 12:11 pm
I think it’s pretty clear Aaron Rodgers is the best QB to ever play. He’s in the top 3 ever at every single aspect of playing the position. If Jameis is half of what Rodgers is, we’ll be thrilled.
September 29th, 2015 at 12:26 pm
Aaron Rodgers is a monster!
“It’s as simple as that” – Lovie Smith aka “Seat is still cold fellas!”
September 29th, 2015 at 12:59 pm
Marcus Mariota has had incredible numbers…..but if you’ve actually watched the Titans games, he has not looked good early the past two weeks
I honestly worry for his safety when they play the Bills next week
September 29th, 2015 at 1:21 pm
Will M.M. always be rated a better qb then Winston?
September 29th, 2015 at 1:24 pm
Joe you know I have said this before, please do not bring up anything the stat geeks say. Remember I stop caring about the spreadsheeters when they tried to sell me that EJ Biggers was better than Ronde Barber. That was enough for me to say never take anything the stat geeks say seriously.
September 29th, 2015 at 1:25 pm
Damn it Joe that picture is too funny.
His face looks the little ceramic black lawn boy that sits out in front of my grandma’s house. She’s got another one fishing over the side of her pool too.
My uncle and mom calls them little Obama. Now I might have to call them little Jameis.
September 29th, 2015 at 2:35 pm
Just keep in mind that PFF isn’t even reviewing All-22 tape when they assign these grades. They grade it off of what we see on television with no idea as to player assignments and other variables.
I don’t mind some of the stats they provide, but I’m not going to live or die on these numbers either.
September 29th, 2015 at 8:06 pm
Jaboo Tha ‘Rassler! lol